Skip to content
The Musical Me

Implementing an Effective Music Assessment Strategy (Without the Tick Sheets)

By Pete Jenkins5 min read

Updated

Implementing an effective music assessment strategy across a primary school is mostly about doing less, better. You need to know whether children are singing, playing, listening and composing a bit better each year. You don't need a tick sheet for every lesson, and nor do your colleagues.

Ofsted's 2023 music report, Striking the right note, is blunt about where primary schools go wrong. It found that "assessment was weak in most of the primary schools visited", and that in many schools with an assessment model, "the assessment focused on whether the curriculum had been covered rather than on what pupils had learned." Where schools did record pupils' work, it was mostly for posterity, or to "prove" coverage in ways that added to teachers' workload. Far fewer leaders used the recordings to judge how well the curriculum was working. As one teacher put it to inspectors: "We tick the boxes and forget about it."

So aim for a system that tells you what children can do and costs teachers minutes, not hours.

Your music assessment strategy: what to assess in each year group

The national curriculum has no levels for music. Its attainment target says only that by the end of each key stage, pupils are expected to "know, apply and understand the matters, skills and processes specified in the relevant programme of study". So your school decides what "on track" sounds like in each year group.

Pick three or four end points for each year group from your curriculum, and make them things you can hear. "Understands pitch" can't be assessed by listening. "Sings a short song in tune with the group" can. For example:

  • Year 1: sings a short song in tune with the class, keeps a steady beat while singing, and copies a short clapped rhythm.
  • Year 4: plays their part in a two-part piece from simple notation, reads rhythms with minims, crotchets, paired quavers and rests, and holds their part in a round.
  • Year 6: holds a part in a three- or four-part round, plays a melody from staff notation within an octave, and composes and writes down an 8-beat or 16-beat pentatonic melody.

Use your own curriculum's end points if it has them. If it doesn't, that's worth knowing before you choose your next scheme, and our guide to choosing a music curriculum shows what progression should look like.

Evidence that's quick to keep: the end-of-unit recording

Short recordings are the best evidence music has, as long as someone listens to them. Use the last 20 minutes of the final lesson of each unit.

  1. Run through the piece once (5 minutes). Tell the class: "Today we're recording, so we can hear how far we've come. Everybody's part matters."
  2. Record the whole class (2 minutes): one take of about a minute, on a school tablet.
  3. Record groups (8 minutes): four to six children at a time, 20 to 30 seconds each, playing or singing their part. Give everyone else a listening job, such as "Listen for whether they finish together."
  4. Listen back (5 minutes). If you recorded the class in the first week of the unit, play that first, then today's, and ask: "What's better?"

With KS1, record the whole class singing, then pairs or small groups keeping the beat or echoing a rhythm, and keep the whole thing to 10 or 15 minutes. Children can answer with their thumbs: "Thumbs up if we kept the beat better today." With KS2, record groups performing their part or composition, let a child run the tablet, and ask them to name one thing that changed, such as finishing together or getting quieter where they'd planned to.

Save each file with the year group, half term and unit in its name, in one shared folder per year group, on school devices and storage only. Check your school's consent list for recordings, and follow its data policy on how long to keep them.

A few things go wrong. The recording eats the whole lesson, so keep groups small and takes short. Children giggle or freeze, so do a practice take you delete, and record often enough that it becomes normal. The tablet is flat, so charge it the day before. The big one is the problem Ofsted found: nobody listens. Put 20 minutes a term in your diary to do it.

Tracking progress without tick-sheet overload

Use one sheet per class per year, with the three or four end points across the top. After listening to the end-of-unit recordings, mark only the children who are clearly not there yet and those clearly beyond. Everyone else is on track, and the blank boxes say so. That takes minutes per class, and it tells next year's teacher exactly who needs a hand.

As music lead, once a term, listen to one class recording from each year group in order. Does Year 3 sound as if it has moved on from Year 2? Where does progress stall? That's the curriculum evaluation Ofsted found few leaders doing, and it shows you where staff need help.

Two more things keep it honest. Judging music by ear is subjective, so listen to a few recordings with a colleague for ten minutes and agree what "on track" sounds like. And some things, like enjoyment and confidence, are worth noticing without tracking.

Children can take part too. A quick reflection sheet, such as our free My Musical Mind, lets KS2 children say what they thought and felt about their performance. Our free Clap a Rhythm patterns make a two-minute check on rhythm reading: the class claps each line and you note who can't yet. When report time comes, you'll have specific things to say, and our example report comments help with the wording.

Start with one year group this half term: agree its end points with the class teacher, record the last lesson of the unit and listen to it together. For feedback inside lessons, which does more for progress than any tracking sheet, see our post on effective feedback in music.

Resources to try